Home Marketing Why A Little Negativity Could Boost Your Sales

Why A Little Negativity Could Boost Your Sales

When Less than Perfect is Just Perfect


Today we’re diving into something that might sound like a total paradox. You know how we all strive for that perfect product or service? The one that’ll blow the competition out of the water? Well, what if I told you that sometimes, it’s the little imperfections that make customers fall head over heels for what you’re offering? No, this isn’t an April Fool’s joke; it’s science. Let’s unpack this, shall we?

Introducing the “Blemishing Effect”

Before you start thinking I’ve lost my marketing marbles, let’s give credit where it’s due. Dr. Danit Ein-Gar of Tel Aviv University, along with Baba Shiv and Zakary Tormala from Stanford University, have opened the door to this fascinating concept they call the “blemishing effect.” Simply put, they’ve found that exposing a small flaw in your product—after initially presenting its positive attributes—can actually increase its appeal.

Confused? Skeptical? Good! That means you’re paying attention. So, why does this happen?

Timing, Scale, and Cognitive Effort

Dr. Ein-Gar explains that the magic sauce of the “blemishing effect” depends on three key variables:

  1. The order of information – Your customer has to hear the good stuff first. If you lead with a flaw, you’re pretty much shooting yourself in the foot.
  2. The magnitude of the flaw – We’re talking small flaws here, like slightly worn packaging or a limited edition color that’s running out—nothing that screams ‘poor quality.’
  3. Cognitive Effort – This one’s crucial. The consumer has to process this information quickly and effortlessly to make a hasty purchase decision.

Get these three factors right, and boom! You’ve got yourself a weirdly appealing product that people didn’t know they needed.

Does It Really Work?

Now, you might be thinking, “This is all fine and dandy in theory, but does it work in the real world?” Well, guess what? Dr. Ein-Gar and her team didn’t just cook this up in some academic kitchen; they actually tested it. They had folks look at hiking boots online, sprinkling in small flaws like damaged packaging, and voilà! The group exposed to the ‘blemished’ product ended up having a higher positive evaluation.

Still not convinced? Think about that rustic coffee shop down the street with the mismatched chairs and chipped coffee mugs. Ever wonder why it’s packed? People appreciate authenticity, and a slight imperfection can make a place or product more relatable and genuine.

When NOT to Use the “Blemishing Effect”

Fair warning! Just like you wouldn’t use hot sauce in every dish, the “blemishing effect” isn’t a one-size-fits-all strategy. If your customer has plenty of time to ponder, reflect, and dissect every detail of your product, this tactic will backfire. Remember, it’s most effective in quick, low-effort buying situations, like impulse purchases.

The Takeaway for Marketers and Brand Managers

Ready for some actionable advice? You know you are! Here’s how you can integrate the “blemishing effect” into your marketing strategies:

  1. Spot the Opportunity – Identify products that would benefit from this counterintuitive approach. Not every product is suitable for this strategy.
  2. Order Matters – Always showcase the positive attributes first. Let the consumer lean toward liking the product before introducing the minor flaw.
  3. The Right Context – Optimal settings for this strategy are high-traffic, low-engagement points like check-out counters, pop-up ads, or even social media scrolls.

Why This Matters to You

You’re not just a marketer; you’re a consumer too. Ever bought something you didn’t plan to, just because it was near the cashier and had a “Last Item” tag? That’s the “blemishing effect” working its magic on you. Being aware of this psychological nuance will make you a more informed consumer—and a marketing ninja!

Embrace the Power of Imperfection

The “blemishing effect” turns conventional wisdom on its head, reminding us that in the quest for perfection, we can overlook the appeal of the authentic, the genuine, and yes, the slightly imperfect. As a marketer, isn’t it exciting to think that your product’s minor flaw could actually be its secret weapon? And as a consumer, it adds a fun twist to the shopping experience

Written by
Ronald Berg

Ronald Berg is a dedicated and experienced journalist, revered for his in-depth coverage and analysis of startups and business strategies. His rich career, spanning over twelve years, is marked by stories that provide clarity and inspiration for budding entrepreneurs. Ronald's expertise lies in shedding light on the challenges and triumphs of startup life. Based in Chicago, he's committed to delivering insightful news that drives the startup community forward.

Related Articles


The Double-Edged Sword of Priming

Have you ever tried to nudge someone subtly toward doing something, like...

Digital MarketingMarketing

Talk or Type? How Voice Tech is Changing What We Share About Ourselves

Remember the days when you had to type out your queries on...


How Ethical Claims Boost Sales in Surprising Ways

You’ve probably found yourself standing in a store aisle, staring at two...


The Link Between Price and Quality

Have you ever wondered why you sometimes opt for that slightly pricier...